← Foresight Advisory Africa

Thursday Commentary

What can one cigarette tell us about the price of smoking?

Although selling cigarettes individually is illegal in Kenya, the practice persists, lowering the cash needed for each purchase. Karambu Muthaura examines what loose-cigarette prices reveal about tobacco taxation, retail enforcement and access to tobacco.

Karambu Muthaura ·

Illustration of a single cigarette beside an open, unbranded packet on a shop counter, with a Nairobi streetscape in the background.

In Nairobi’s central business district, cigarettes are openly sold one at a time by kiosks and street vendors. The practice raises a direct question about enforcement of Kenya’s tobacco-control laws: how has a prohibited form of retail sale become so visible in everyday commerce?

Section 18(1) of the Tobacco Control Act, 2007 (Cap. 245A) prohibits the sale of cigarettes except in packages containing at least ten cigarettes. Section 15(1) separately prohibits the sale of tobacco products to anyone under 18. These are distinct legal obligations: one governs the form in which cigarettes may be sold; the other protects young people from tobacco sales. Their effectiveness depends on what happens at the point of sale.

There is an excise question here too. When cigarette duty rises, public discussion often centres on the price of a packet. Yet selling cigarettes individually lowers the amount of cash a purchaser needs at any one time. How effectively are taxation and retail enforcement working together to reduce access to tobacco?

The price of one

A cigarette sold individually can cost more per stick than one bought as part of a packet. A person who buys cigarettes one at a time may therefore pay more over time for the same quantity. At the moment of purchase, however, the cash required is smaller. Someone who cannot afford a packet may still have enough for a single cigarette. This is one reason the loose-cigarette market deserves closer attention in tobacco-tax policy.

The distinction is between the cumulative cost of continued smoking and the immediate cash needed for the next purchase. Both matter. A packet price helps assess the cost of cigarettes, while the price charged for a loose stick helps explain how tobacco remains within immediate financial reach.

Dividing the packet price by the number of cigarettes gives an average per-stick price within the packet. It does not tell us what a retailer actually charges for a loose cigarette. That requires direct observation. Research published in the journal Tobacco Control, examining loose-cigarette markets across several low- and middle-income countries and retail data from 16 African countries, found that loose cigarettes were generally more expensive per stick than cigarettes bought in packs. It also found that loose-stick prices can respond differently to tax increases, partly because prices cluster around small currency denominations.

For policymakers, this creates a practical measurement question: after an excise increase, how much does the price of a packet change, and how much does the price of a single stick change? Monitoring only packet prices risks missing an important part of the market.

The evidence behind the concern

Kenyan survey findings show how established this practice has been. The International Tobacco Control (ITC) Kenya National Report, based on survey waves conducted in 2012 and 2018, reported that 82 per cent of smokers surveyed in 2018 had purchased loose cigarettes on their most recent purchase. The report described the proportion as essentially unchanged from 2012. These findings document a persistent compliance challenge across the two survey periods.

More recent evidence brings the concern directly to young people. The 2024 Data on Youth and Tobacco (DaYTA) Kenya survey found that 78.73 per cent of adolescents who had ever purchased manufactured cigarettes and were included in the analysis reported buying single sticks on their last purchase. This is not a proportion of all adolescents; it relates specifically to respondents who had purchased manufactured cigarettes and answered the relevant question. Even with that qualification, the finding shows how prominent loose sales were among adolescents who had accessed manufactured cigarettes.

A loose cigarette is also separated from the package carrying the product’s health warnings. The purchaser generally takes away the cigarette, not the warning-bearing pack. This reduces the opportunity for the package warning to accompany the product and remain visible to the purchaser. Research on loose-cigarette markets identifies this separation from packaging as a tobacco-control concern.

Compliance must reach the retail counter

My experience in excise administration has taught me to ask what each compliance check actually establishes. An inspection may confirm that a packet bears a genuine excise stamp. That does not establish that the cigarettes are subsequently being sold in the form permitted by tobacco-control law. A tax-compliant packet can still be opened and its contents sold individually, contrary to section 18. Tax administration and tobacco-control enforcement must therefore examine successive stages of the same product’s journey.

The visibility of loose-cigarette sales in Nairobi’s CBD makes the enforcement question particularly pressing. What happens after a breach is identified? Are retailers informed of their obligations? Are appropriate sanctions applied? Do follow-up inspections establish whether the prohibited practice has stopped?

A sustained response should combine retailer education, routine inspections and consistent enforcement. Public-health and revenue authorities should share relevant findings so that attention to tax compliance is accompanied by attention to how tobacco is sold. Retail monitoring should also consider whether sales to minors are being prevented, as required by section 15.

Price monitoring should support that work. Recording packet and single-stick prices at the same outlets before and after excise changes would help establish how retail prices respond. Recording breaches, the action taken and the results of follow-up visits would help assess whether enforcement is changing retail behaviour.

Kenya already has a legal prohibition on selling cigarettes in packages containing fewer than ten sticks. The task is to make that protection effective in everyday commerce. The next review of tobacco excise should examine the prices consumers actually face alongside compliance with retail restrictions.

An openly prohibited practice should prompt a visible, sustained enforcement response. The protection promised by tobacco-control law must reach the retail counter.

Sources and further reading

Kenya Law: Tobacco Control Act, Cap. 245A (revised to 31 December 2022)

ITC Project: ITC Kenya National Report: Findings from the Wave 1 and 2 Surveys (2012–2018), May 2021

APHRC / Ministry of Health / KNBS / Development Gateway: Tobacco and Nicotine Use Among Adolescents in Kenya: Findings from the DaYTA Survey, 2024

Gallien, M., Occhiali, G. and Ross, H.: An overlooked market: loose cigarettes, informal vendors and their implications for tobacco taxation, Tobacco Control

Related articles

Join the conversation

Share a perspective, ask a question, or reply to a reader below.

No comments published yet. Be the first to share your perspective.

Leave a comment

Readers’ comments and replies are reviewed before publication. Please keep the discussion respectful and relevant. Your chosen name and comment will be public once approved. No email address is required.

← Thursday Commentary · All articles