← Foresight Advisory Africa

Monday Series · Health Taxes 101

Health Taxes 101 | Part 4: The Tax That Shrinks While You Sleep

A health tax can lose its bite without Parliament reducing the rate. In Part 4 of Health Taxes 101, Karambu Muthaura explains how inflation and rising incomes affect specific taxes, and why clear adjustment rules matter.

Karambu Muthaura ·

Health Taxes 101 Part 4: The Tax That Shrinks While You Sleep. Coins turn into orange sand in an hourglass, illustrating inflation eroding an unchanged health tax.

Can a health tax become weaker without Parliament voting to reduce it?

Yes. Sometimes, all it takes is leaving the rate unchanged.

In Part 3, we examined why the design of an excise tax matters. A specific tax, charged as a fixed amount per cigarette or unit of alcohol, can make the system simpler and reduce the advantages enjoyed by cheaper products. But a fixed amount has a weakness: it stays still while the economy moves.

Inflation erodes its value. Rising incomes can weaken its influence on purchasing decisions. A tax that looked substantial when it was introduced may gradually lose its bite.

How a tax loses value

Imagine a specific excise duty of KSh 100 per unit. Assume inflation averages 5 per cent annually and the tax remains unchanged for four years.

At the end of that period, the KSh 100 would be worth approximately KSh 82 in the purchasing power of the starting year. Its real value would have fallen by almost 18 per cent.

The amount on the tax return would still read KSh 100. The law might look unchanged. Yet the economic value of the tax would be smaller.

This is an illustration, not an inflation forecast. It shows why maintaining the same number is not necessarily maintaining the same policy.

Inflation is only half the story

For a health tax, protecting its real value is important. But the public health question goes further: how affordable is the product becoming?

Affordability compares prices with people’s incomes. A product can become more expensive in shillings and still become easier to afford if incomes rise faster than its price.

Suppose a product’s price increases by 5 per cent while a consumer’s income increases by 10 per cent. The product now takes a smaller share of that income to purchase.

This is why an inflation adjustment alone may be insufficient. WHO’s tobacco-tax guidance calls for taxation to account for both inflation and economic growth so that tobacco becomes less affordable. The objective depends on what happens to retail prices relative to incomes, not merely on the percentage increase in the tax rate.

An unchanged tax does not automatically mean consumption will rise. Prices, incomes, regulation and consumer behaviour all matter. But failing to review the tax can weaken one of the tools intended to discourage harmful consumption.

Two different jobs for tax policy

There are two tasks that policymakers should distinguish.

First, protect the tax from inflation. Regular adjustment, often called indexation, helps preserve the purchasing power of a fixed tax amount.

Second, reduce affordability. This requires tax policy strong enough to help retail prices rise faster than incomes over time, supported by monitoring of actual market prices.

These tasks are connected, but they are not interchangeable. An inflation adjustment maintains a baseline. Further increases may be needed to achieve the health objective.

WHO’s “3 by 35” initiative reflects the ambition to make harmful products less affordable through taxation. It calls for an increase of at least 50 per cent in the real prices of tobacco, alcohol and sugary drinks by 2035, taking national circumstances into account. This is a target for inflation-adjusted prices, not simply a 50 per cent increase in statutory tax rates.

Kenya’s experience: a lesson in legal clarity

Kenya has practical experience with inflation adjustment. KRA’s September 2022 public notice described the annual adjustment of specific excise rates under the legal framework then in force.

The Finance Act, 2023 subsequently repealed section 10 of the Excise Duty Act, which had provided the mechanism for inflation adjustment. However, the consolidated Act published as at 1 July 2025 retains wording and a formula concerning inflation adjustment in the First Schedule.

These provisions should be read together with care. The remaining schedule language should not simply be presented as proof that the former mechanism continues unchanged. The policy case is for a clear, coherent legal framework specifying who makes the adjustment, when it takes effect and how it is calculated.

A tax system should not leave businesses, administrators and the public guessing about how a routine adjustment is supposed to work.

Why a predictable rule matters

I have long argued for a clear rule for inflation adjustment. Its value extends beyond the annual revenue discussion.

It improves planning. A published formula and an established adjustment date help manufacturers, importers and other businesses prepare their pricing, systems and compliance processes.

It protects the value of the tax per unit. Without adjustment, inflation erodes that value. Total revenue will still depend on sales volumes, compliance and other factors, so indexation is not a guarantee of rising collections.

It makes policy choices more transparent. Maintaining the real value of an existing tax is different from introducing an additional real increase. A clear framework allows that distinction to be explained openly.

It supports health objectives. Indexation helps prevent inflation from weakening a specific tax, while periodic reviews can assess whether further increases are needed to reduce affordability.

A rule can reduce repeated bargaining over routine adjustments. It cannot eliminate political choices, industry influence or the need for scrutiny.

What about the cost of living?

The concern that excise increases can raise consumer prices deserves a serious answer.

Their contribution to overall inflation depends on the size of the increase, how much businesses pass on to consumers and the weight of the affected products in household spending. It should be assessed using evidence rather than assumed to be negligible.

Health-tax policy must also recognise the position of people who continue consuming taxed products, particularly those on low incomes. Tobacco taxation, for example, should work alongside accessible cessation support.

But allowing harmful products to become progressively more affordable also has costs: illness, treatment expenses and lost household income. Those consequences belong in the same policy discussion.

What Kenya and other African countries should do

For Kenya, the priority is a coherent statutory framework that protects specific health taxes against inflation and provides for regular affordability reviews.

The framework should identify a published index, a predictable adjustment date, clear administrative responsibilities and transparent treatment of any exceptions. Further increases can then be considered against explicit health and fiscal objectives.

For countries adopting specific health taxes, these arrangements should be built into the design from the beginning.

A specific tax is not a policy that can be set once and forgotten. Its effectiveness must be maintained.

Three things to remember

  1. An unchanged specific tax loses real value when prices in the wider economy rise.
  2. Inflation adjustment protects the tax’s value; reducing affordability requires attention to retail prices and incomes.
  3. Clear legal rules and regular review make health-tax policy more predictable and effective.

A question to leave with you

If inflation quietly weakens a tax every year, why should protecting its value depend on repeatedly reopening the same political argument?

Next in Health Taxes 101: Part 5.

Sources and further reading

World Health Organization, WHO Technical Manual on Tobacco Tax Policy and Administration (2021).

World Health Organization, Raising Taxes on Tobacco.

World Health Organization, The 3 by 35 Initiative.

Kenya Revenue Authority, Inflation Adjustment on Specific Rates Applicable under the Excise Duty Act and Miscellaneous Fees and Levies Act (September 2022).

Republic of Kenya, Excise Duty Act, consolidated as at 1 July 2025, including section 10 and the First Schedule.

Related articles

Join the conversation

Share a perspective, ask a question, or reply to a reader below.

No comments published yet. Be the first to share your perspective.

Leave a comment

Readers’ comments and replies are reviewed before publication. Please keep the discussion respectful and relevant. Your chosen name and comment will be public once approved. No email address is required.

← Monday Series · All articles