← Foresight Advisory Africa

Monday Series · Health Taxes 101

Health Taxes 101 | Part 3: Why the Design of a Tax Matters

A tax rate and a tax structure are not the same thing. Why specific, ad valorem and mixed excise taxes produce different results for prices, consumption and public health.

Karambu Muthaura ·

Health Taxes 101, Part 3: Why the Design of a Tax Matters. By Karambu Muthaura.

If two countries raise tobacco excise duty by the same percentage, will they achieve the same public health results? Not necessarily. The effect depends not only on the rate but also on the way the tax is designed, how it translates into retail prices and whether consumers can switch to cheaper products.

In Part 2, we examined how higher prices can discourage harmful consumption. Today, we look at the less visible question behind those prices: how is the tax calculated?

Three ways to structure an excise tax

A specific tax is charged as a fixed amount per unit, such as a sum per 1,000 cigarettes or per centilitre of pure alcohol. The tax on a unit does not depend on its selling price.

An ad valorem tax is charged as a percentage of a defined value, such as the ex-factory price or retail selling price. Higher-value products generally attract more duty in absolute terms, while cheaper products attract less.

A mixed tax combines specific and ad valorem elements. Some systems also set a minimum specific amount so that low-priced products cannot fall below a tax floor.

These structures are distinct from tiers, under which different products or price bands face different rates. A tax may be specific and still be tiered. That distinction matters.

Why structure matters for health

For tobacco, the WHO generally favours a simple, uniform specific excise tax, or a mixed system with a strong specific component. A uniform specific tax reduces the tax advantage enjoyed by cheaper cigarettes and can narrow price gaps between brands. This makes trading down to a cheaper brand less attractive than under a purely value-based system.

Value-based taxes can also create valuation disputes, particularly where the tax base relies on declared producer or import prices. Tiered systems introduce another risk: products may be positioned or reformulated to qualify for a lower rate.

Specific taxes are comparatively straightforward to administer because quantities can be measured and verified. But they have an important weakness: unless the rates are adjusted, inflation and income growth can make harmful products increasingly affordable. The structure must therefore be supported by an adequate rate and regular review.

Kenya’s tobacco tax journey

Kenya’s experience shows why this is not merely a theoretical debate. Its cigarette excise system has moved through ad valorem taxation, tiered specific rates and mixed arrangements. Historical research documented how price bands encouraged strategic positioning of brands and how cigarette affordability could rise even when nominal taxes appeared high.

The Excise Duty Act, 2015 marked a shift towards specific taxation, although filtered and plain cigarettes initially continued to attract different rates. Amendments effective in December 2024 brought the two categories under a uniform specific rate of KSh 4,100 per 1,000 sticks. This was a significant structural change, but the effectiveness of any specific rate still depends on subsequent adjustments and its effect on retail affordability.

Kenya’s experience also illustrates that sound tax policy and effective administration must work together. Excise stamps, production monitoring and track-and-trace controls help protect the tax base, but they cannot compensate for a poorly designed rate structure.

Alcohol: tax the alcohol, but examine the exceptions

For alcohol, a specific tax based on the quantity of pure alcohol has a clear public health rationale: it links the tax base to ethanol content rather than simply to the volume or selling price of the beverage. Kenya introduced alcohol-content-based rates for several beverage categories in December 2024.

However, a tax based on pure alcohol is not necessarily uniform across beverages. The schedule has distinguished beer and wine from spirits, and has also provided a preferential rate for qualifying small independent brewers. A preferential statutory rate is not the same as a remission: the former is written into the rate schedule for an eligible category; the latter is a separate relief mechanism subject to its own legal conditions.

These distinctions deserve scrutiny. Where one centilitre of alcohol is taxed differently depending on the beverage or producer, policymakers should be able to explain the objective, the expected benefits and the possible consequences for consumption, competition and revenue. The existence of a lower rate is not, by itself, proof that the policy is unjustified; it is a reason to test the justification against the intended public health outcome.

A lesson from the Philippines

The Philippines provides another useful example. Its 2012 Sin Tax Reform Act simplified a complex, multi-tier tobacco tax system and introduced a path towards more uniform rates. The reforms were associated with substantial growth in tobacco excise revenue, demonstrating that simpler structures can support both fiscal and health objectives when accompanied by effective implementation.

What should policymakers ask?

A headline increase in excise duty is only the beginning of the analysis. We should ask whether it raises the price of the cheapest harmful product, discourages switching to cheaper alternatives, is administratively enforceable and keeps pace with inflation and income growth.

For Kenya and other African countries, the lesson is not that every product must be taxed identically. It is that differences in tax treatment should be deliberate, transparent and supported by evidence. A good tax structure is one that advances the policy objective rather than creating avoidable loopholes.

Three things to remember

  1. A tax rate and a tax structure are not the same thing. Both determine the effect on prices and behaviour.
  2. Uniform specific taxes are particularly valuable for tobacco, provided the rates are sufficiently high and regularly adjusted.
  3. Preferential rates, tiers, exemptions and remissions require separate legal and policy analysis; they should not be treated as interchangeable.

A question to leave with you

Before celebrating an excise duty increase, ask this: what will it do to the price of the cheapest product on the shelf?

Next Monday: Part 4 of Health Taxes 101 will examine inflation, affordability and why a tax that stays unchanged can lose its effectiveness.

References and further reading

World Health Organization (2021), WHO Technical Manual on Tobacco Tax Policy and Administration.
Nargis et al. (2015), Cigarette Taxation in Kenya at the Crossroads.
Republic of Kenya, Excise Duty Act, 2015, as amended, and relevant schedules.
Republic of Kenya, Tax Laws (Amendment) Act, 2024.
Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids, materials on tobacco tax reform in the Philippines.

Related articles

Join the conversation

Share a perspective, ask a question, or reply to a reader below.

No comments published yet. Be the first to share your perspective.

Leave a comment

Readers’ comments and replies are reviewed before publication. Please keep the discussion respectful and relevant. Your chosen name and comment will be public once approved. No email address is required.

← Monday Series · All articles